The Demand For Self-Government In Cornwall

Last week the New Statesman magazine, an influential voice on the centre-left of British politics, featured an unusually sympathetic piece by the journalist Tim Wigmore examining the socio-economic decline of Cornwall, the UK’s south-western Celtic nation. The claim that the region, officially an administrative county of England and long synonymous with the holiday-homes and boutique B&Bs of the metropolitan elites, was “…poorer than Lithuania and Hungary” drew some interesting reactions. This week he has a further article highlighting the peninsula’s demands for greater autonomy in line with the “devolution” of executive and legislative powers granted to Wales and Scotland by Westminster. Given the Statesman’s traditional hostility to any and all forms of “Celtic nationalism”, however innocuous, this is a rare display of understanding by a publication normally associated with a quasi-liberal type of “Greater England” unionism.

“In George Osborne’s last budget, Cornwall gained greater powers over health, transport, skills and business support.

“In the last 15-20 years there’s been a real rekindling of interest in Cornish language, culture and Cornish history,” observes George Eustice, the Conservative MP for Camborne and Redruth.

More signs are in Cornish, and the Saint Piran’s Flag is an increasingly common sight in houses and cars in the Duchy. In 2001, in response to Labour’s call for “regions” to ask for devolution, 50,000 Cornish, a tenth of the county, signed declarations in support of a National Cornish Assembly.

In Camborne I meet Steve Richardson, chair of the local party branch of Mebyon Kernow, which describes itself as the Party for Cornwall. He was also a candidate in the last general election.

There are two things immediately noticeable about Richardson: the Cornish Pirates rugby shirt he is wearing and, more surprisingly, the thick West Midlands drawl to his accent. Richardson only moved to Cornwall in 2008.

“We just wanted to get involved in the local community. I became interested in politics for the first time and that’s why I joined Mebyon Kernow,” Richardson tells me. “Mebyon Kernow is very inclusive. Quite often people think of Cornish nationalism as being about Cornwall for the Cornish – it’s not, it’s all about Cornwall for the people of Cornwall, wherever they’re from.”

Like many in Mebyon Kernow, Richardson has watched events in Scotland closely and admits to “supporting” the yes campaign. And there are some clear parallels between Mebyon Kernow and the SNP. Both claim not to be motivated by winning greater powers, but using it for progressive ends.

“We want Cornwall to be self-determining but we also want to create social justice,” Richardson says.

Mebyon Kernow’s case for giving Cornwall greater powers rests on three parts. First, Richardson argues that Cornwall’s Celtic culture is “really distinctive” from the rest of England, and needs to be recognised as such.

“Cornwall’s a country for a start, rather than a county,” he says.

“A massive democratic deficit,” also motivates Mebyon Kernow and Richardson. “Per person we’re actually massively under-represented by elected politicians”.

The third argument for greater powers rests on the Duchy’s “history of being left behind”, as Richardson puts it. “Cornwall has got the worst economy in the UK…”

Yet, 64 years after it was formed, Mebyon Kernow is still waiting for its electoral breakthrough. The party has only four of Cornwall’s 123 councillors, even if this is more than the Greens or Ukip have in the county.

Perhaps Mebyon Kernow’s moment might never come. Either way, its 600 members, over one per cent of the county’s population, are not easily deterred.”

One of the big issues for the small Celtic nation is of course the behind-the-scenes influence of the so-called Duchy of Cornwall, the hereditary fiefdom of Prince Charles, which owns vast tracts of land in the south-west of Britain. This is valued at some nine hundred million euros (over one billion dollars) and is part of the nearly two billion euros in assets possessed by the House of Windsor, the British royal family. For Mebyon Kernow and others it remains one of the stumbling blocks to greater democratisation of regional government in the country.

Advertisements

8 comments

  1. I admit I’m a bit out of the loop these days, but the feeling I have is that Cornish Nationalism has at best been stalled for the past few years. A glance at the Wikipedia page seems to confirm this. Various groups and bodies that were pushing the agenda, looking into the constitution and how it might be changed etc. seem to have been mostly dormant recently. The district councils were abolished some years ago, with everything centralised in a single unitary body, Cornwall Council. There are only a handful of MK councillors, and the cabinet system means they probably don’t get much of a look in. There were three LibDem MPs who spoke up for Cornwall now and again in Westminster, but they were all replaced by Tories last year, as part of the UK-wide LibDem meltdown.

    Support for the language, always rather tokenistic, has also been scaled back along with its funding. Possibly that was the plan all along : set up an office at County Hall to take over co-ordination from the existing voluntary bodies, throw in a bit of short-term funding as bait, and then after a decent interval, scale it all back.

    1. I get that feeling too. Very few “new bloods” seem to be joining MK or supporting the attempts at linguistic equality. Most of the faces are the same ones that were there in the 1980s and ’90s. I fear a generational break may come to pass when that group of activists are no longer around.

  2. Maybe there’s no point in cornwall seeking independence if they arent arsed for limited self government……..

    1. Cornwall doesn’t have enough political clout, and is already too heavily anglicised to achieve much on its own (sadly!) A few years back it might have progressed as part of a broader, UK-wide decentralisation/federal programme, or even at an earlier date still, as part of a pan-Celtic movement. Neither has come about, and as a result Scotland will most probably be independent in a few years’ time, effectively leaving Wales and Cornwall in the lurch.

      Wales is pretty well stalled at present, Plaid Cymru doesn’t seem able to win enough support outwith the Welsh-speaking areas, so that UKIP seems to be replacing it as the “party of protest” in parts of the South. UKIP may well have as many assembly seats as Plaid after the May elections. Interesting time, maybe?

      The difference between developments in Scotland and in Wales over the past few years are so striking they would be worthy of a serious, unbiased study.

        1. According to a Welsh blog I read the other day (but can’t for the moment find), it’s mixture of two factors. Along the North coast, UKIP support is probably from ‘conservative’ older English immigrants, pensioners etc. But down in the Eastern Valleys the support seems to be from pissed-off Labour supporters. Strange bedfellows, but that’s what you get with a “plague on all their houses” type of party.

            1. See here, esspecially comment #17 :

              Jacothenorth.net/blog/ukip-uniting-wales/

              ‘Cwtch’ = wenglish for cuddle or embrace
              ‘Crachach’ = a sort of intellectual welsh-speaking mafia, academics, politicos, the people who get to be on all the committees, I’m sure you have their equivalent …

Comments are closed.